+1 843-757-4444
Nestled in the heart of Hilton Head Island, La Pizzeria is a true gem for pizza lovers seeking an authentic slice of Italian-American tradition. This charming pizza restaurant at 1460 Fording Island Rd Suite 230 invites locals and visitors alike to indulge in a masterful celebration of classic and inventive pies, serving up an irresistible fusion of fresh ingredients and heartfelt craftsmanship.
Stepping into La Pizzeria, you are instantly transported to the bustling pizzerias of New Jersey and New York, a feeling echoed fondly by customer Carrie Quinn, who notes the welcoming atmosphere and spot-on decor. The aroma of melting mozzarella and freshly baked dough fills the air, marrying perfectly with the scent of robust tomato sauce and fragrant herbs—an olfactory prelude to the flavorful journey ahead.
The menu itself is a treasure trove for pizza aficionados. From the crisp, crunchy Margherita with fresh basil and velvety mozzarella to the hearty, satisfying Philly Steak loaded with tender steak, peppers, and mushrooms, every selection is crafted to ignite your taste buds. The Veggie X Large satisfies even the most discerning palate with a vibrant mix of onions, mushrooms, green peppers, spinach, and black olives atop a rich tomato base. Not to be missed are their beloved Sicilian and Brooklyn-style options, mentioned enthusiastically by Jennifer Hubner and others for their quality and authentic flavors.
La Pizzeria doesn’t stop at just pizza. The menu extends to tempting Italian classics such as the creamy Fettuccini Con Pollo Y Camarón, savory Calzone Al Pesto, and delightful Stromboli. For a sweet ending, their Tiramisu and Cannoli provide a delicate and indulgent finish, echoing the loving, homemade touch customers have come to expect.
Health-conscious diners are also well served with their gluten-free options, like the 10” and 12” GF Plain Cheese pizzas made with the same commitment to flavor and freshness. Refreshing beverage selections including classic 20oz Coke, zingy Ginger Ale, and hydrating Powerade complement the meal perfectly.
The dining experience at La Pizzeria is warm and personal, with attentive and friendly staff who make you feel like part of the family. Frequent visitors rave about the exceptional customer service and genuine hospitality that make every visit special. The casual, cozy setting is perfect for families, couples, or anyone craving the best pizza on Hilton Head Island.
In short, La Pizzeria is not just a pizza spot—it’s a heartfelt homage to the great pizzerias of the Northeast, right in South Carolina. Whether you’re savoring their thin, crunchy crust or delighting in a hearty panini, every bite bursts with passion and authenticity. La Pizzeria stands proudly as the place to find memorable, lovingly prepared Italian comfort food on Hilton Head Island.
For your next craving, call +1 843-757-4444 or visit 1460 Fording Island Rd Suite 230. La Pizzeria promises a true taste sensation that will have you returning time and time again.
Very cute pizzeria. Has the entire feel, decor, smell… Pizza is great. We were told by a local to order a Sicilian and we were not disappointed. Quality ingredients were used and you could tell the pies were made with love. Pretty sure family-owned establishment. Will definitely be returning and recommend others to try
I’m so happy I found La Pizzeria today. The inside looks exactly like every NJ/NY pizzeria I’ve walked into my entire life. Easy to order online and since I live on the Old South Golf Course I’m right around the corner. Great customer service. Everyone is super friendly. The garlic knots are heaven. Your red sauce is NJ/NY perfection. Pizza is great, chicken parmigiana is the best in the LowCountry. My 1 and only complaint was the cannoli. No filling at all in the middle, which is the best part, but it still was delicious. I will definitely be ordering again and again and again.
Finally! We found a very thin pizza crust option that has crunch on the entire pie, not just the crust! La pizzeria has the best pizza! We had the Margherita. The meat sauce for the pasta was extremely flavorful with lots of meat in the tomato based sauce. Very fresh tasting- homemade. Would visit again for sure!
Best pizza place in the area hands down! We have been visiting for the past few years and every year we stop on our way in and on our way out the food is amazing and the service is exceptional! Our waiter remember us from last year. Hubby got the wings, my daughter had the cheese less pizza and I always get the salad and pizza. The food is always fresh and so good.
I’ve only ever ordered online and gone to pick up so I can’t comment anything about the restaurant itself other than it has a great atmosphere when you walk in, nice and clean, and the staff are polite. Now if you want something that absolutely hits every single time you get it, than get the Italian Panini. It is an absolute banger of a sandwich and it never disappoints. I was going to snap a picture of it but uuuh, you can already guess what happened to it
Brought out the nice china and crystal tonite for a celebration of our 37th anniversary tonight, with all the heavy lifting done by La Pizzeria in Tanger 2, Bluffton! We had their excellent eggplant parm and chicken parm, both served with penne. We also had their delicious meatballs and sausage and peppers! We bought an extra container of sauce but it wasn't needed because all meals had plenty, so I'll use that for something of my own later. Finally we added a slice of their Sicilian pizza and their homemade bread. I have loved this guy's sauce and food since he was on Gibbet Road, right around the corner from me. Also his pizza is one of the best in Bluffton! Topped it all off with a very nice slice of New York style cheesecake and a tiramisu! Oh, and by the way, my wife and I had our own Pizzeria for 7 years in Litchfield Connecticut and were written about in Connecticut magazine and the New York Times, so I do have a bit of an Italian pedigree!
Delicious pizza! We got an X-Large meat lovers (without sausage) and it was spectacular! The girl working was on it, very helpful, quick, but also had a laid back personality. We had a great experience and would definitely recommend!